Tasting an oil is not an expert's gesture. It's paying attention. With a glass, a little oil and five minutes, anyone can understand why one extra virgin is not like another.
1. Temperature
Pour a couple of spoonfuls into a small glass and warm it with your hand, covering it with the other. Oil releases its aromas best at around 28 °C.
2. Smell
Uncover and smell. Look for the fruitiness: green (grass, leaf, tomato plant, artichoke) or ripe (apple, almond, flowers)? An early-harvest oil smells of freshly cut fields.
3. Taste
Take a small sip and let it coat your mouth. Draw a little air between your teeth to spread the aroma. Identify the fruitiness again, now on the palate.
4. Bitterness and pungency
At the end come two key sensations: bitterness on the tongue and pungency in the throat. Far from being flaws, they are the signature of a fresh oil rich in polyphenols. The Picual carries them marked; the Royal, more subtle.
Frequently asked questions
How can you tell a good extra virgin olive oil?
By the balance between fruitiness, bitterness and pungency, and the absence of defects (rancid, vinegary). A good EVOO smells and tastes of fresh fruit.
Is bitterness bad in olive oil?
No. Bitterness is a virtue: it indicates freshness and the presence of polyphenols. Very mild oils are usually riper or older.
At what temperature is oil tasted?
Around 28 °C, warming the glass with your hand to release the aromas.